Arbitrary and Capricious

To live outside the law you must be honest *

January 25, 2005

Caballes consternation


" Uh, no, sorry, I was hoping maybe you could explain the majority opinion to me."


Scott in Austin has much more to say about Caballes, with a set of links to some mostly dismayed commentators.

- 11:50 AM  

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Newer Post Older Post Home
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
My photo
Skelly
View my complete profile
* © 1966 Bob Dylan


A Public Defender Blog


"ARBITRARY AND CAPRICIOUS":
"absence of a rational connection between the facts found and the choice made"
"Everyone, even the guilty criminal--especially the guilty criminal!--needs a companion, a friend, someone to stand with him and for him...
The defense lawyer's job is to force the system to acknowledge that the defendant is not just a social misfit, or a statistic, or a criminal, but a human being with hopes and dreams and fears. A human being who, like any of us, stands in need of repentance and redemption..
The question for the Christian lawyer is not, 'How can you work to get a guilty person off?' The real question is, 'Will you stand by this person, this flawed and sinful human being, and speak a word on his behalf?'

  • Joseph G. Allegretti, The Lawyer's Calling

  • Twitter Updates

    Twitter Updates

      follow me on Twitter

      Arbitrary

      • 43rd State Blues
      • A cat's eye view of the statehouse
      • A Public Defender
      • Abolish the Death Penalty
      • ACS Blog
      • Alaskablawg
      • All Roads to Idaho
      • Angry Pregnant Lawyer
      • Anonymous Law Student
      • Austindefender
      • Between a Laugh and a Tear
      • Blawg Republic
      • Blonde Justice
      • Boise Daily Photo
      • Capital Defense Weekly
      • Compassion in Juvenile Sentencing
      • Confrontation Blog
      • Court-Martial Trial Practice
      • Courthouse Confessions
      • Courthouse Dogs
      • Creek Running North
      • Crim Law
      • Criminal Appeal
      • CrimProf Blog
      • Days and Nights with the Unbored
      • Defending People
      • Doubtslinger
      • EuroYank
      • F-Words
      • Federal Criminal Defense Investigator
      • Federal Defenders of Eastern Washington
      • Five Borough Defense
      • Five Tomatoes to Freedom, Esq.
      • Fort Boise Weblog
      • Go West, Young Tex
      • Grits for Breakfast
      • Harmful Error
      • How the Other Half Works
      • I Speak of Dreams
      • Idaho Criminal Defense Blog
      • Idajevo
      • Idiosyncracies of the Creative Lawyer
      • Incorrigible Dicta
      • Indefensible
      • Indignant Indigent
      • Infinity Ranch
      • Injustice in Seattle
      • International Bridges to Justice
      • Iowa Public Defender
      • Ipse Dixit
      • Joe Bageant
      • Jon's Jail Journal
      • Juvienation
      • Kansas Defenders
      • Law of Criminal Defense
      • Law with Grace
      • Lawyers with Depression
      • Lawyers With Depression Blog
      • Magic Cookie
      • Melissa Runs
      • Minor Wisdom
      • Mostly Plants
      • Mountain Goat Report
      • Notes from the (Legal) Underground
      • Oly Ost
      • Olympia Daily Photo
      • Orcinus
      • P. D. Investigator Network
      • PD Jay
      • Petition for Review
      • Prison Dogs
      • Public Defender Blog Guide
      • Public Defender Dude
      • Public Defender Investigator
      • Public Defender Stuff
      • Reclaiming Futures
      • Saucy Vixen
      • SCOIDBlog
      • Scoplaw
      • Sentencing Law & Policy
      • Simple Justice
      • Southern Appeal
      • Thanks But No Thanks
      • That Lawyer Dude
      • The 13th Juror
      • The Contemplative Lawyer
      • The Defense Perspective
      • The Fall of '55
      • The Imbroglio
      • The Legal Reader
      • The Long View
      • The Menagerie
      • The Mindful Mission
      • The Other Side of the Ocean
      • The Public Defender Experience
      • The Rural Bus Route
      • The Third Avenue
      • The Underblawg
      • This Recording
      • Trial Ad Notes
      • Underdog Defense Blog
      • Unpublished Opinion
      • WA State Criminal Defense
      • Where's Travis McGee?
      • Will Lawyer for Food
      • Will Work For Favorable Dicta
      • Woman of the Law
      • Wonderland or Not
      • Yakima Gulag
      • Yodelling Llama
      • Z The Legal Blog

      Capricious

      • "public pretender" (66)
      • Alaska (25)
      • animals (74)
      • Arizona (13)
      • Arkansas (4)
      • bad cop (14)
      • bad lawyer (41)
      • bad prosecutor (29)
      • Balkans (13)
      • Baltics (5)
      • BigLaw (16)
      • Blaine County (17)
      • blogs (256)
      • Boise (37)
      • books (21)
      • California (94)
      • Canada (8)
      • Canyon County (18)
      • cartoons (9)
      • caseload (94)
      • cats (32)
      • CLE (18)
      • clients (119)
      • Coeur d'Alene (9)
      • colleagues (387)
      • Colorado (12)
      • Constitution (67)
      • creative writing (24)
      • death penalty (26)
      • dependency (11)
      • depression (31)
      • dogs (47)
      • drug court (15)
      • Dylan (8)
      • Eastern Europe (8)
      • fashion (10)
      • Florida (51)
      • Georgia (27)
      • Grant County (37)
      • Guantanamo (10)
      • Hawaii (4)
      • history (39)
      • How Can You Defend A Guilty Client? (33)
      • IAC (11)
      • Idaho (329)
      • Illinois (19)
      • in court (101)
      • Indiana (12)
      • interns (33)
      • Iowa (10)
      • jail (49)
      • jobs (35)
      • judges (80)
      • juvenile (169)
      • Kansas (3)
      • Kentucky (19)
      • law students (51)
      • LiveJournal (28)
      • Louisiana (27)
      • marijuana (15)
      • Massachusetts (2)
      • methamphetamine (82)
      • Michigan (1)
      • Minnesota (9)
      • Mississippi (2)
      • Missouri (10)
      • Montana (27)
      • movies (17)
      • murder (133)
      • music (31)
      • Myspace (30)
      • Nebraska (3)
      • Nevada (11)
      • New Mexico (8)
      • new p.d. (54)
      • New York (14)
      • North Carolina (11)
      • North Dakota (6)
      • Ohio (16)
      • Olympia (133)
      • Oregon (21)
      • Pennsylvania (5)
      • pets (38)
      • photos (104)
      • police (46)
      • politics (149)
      • prison (56)
      • prosecutors (38)
      • quotes (6)
      • Samoa (7)
      • Seattle (45)
      • Skelly Wright (10)
      • South Carolina (10)
      • spam (7)
      • Tacoma (23)
      • Tennessee (11)
      • Texas (24)
      • Tri-Cities (6)
      • trial (96)
      • TV (34)
      • Twin Falls (85)
      • Utah (29)
      • Virginia (10)
      • Washington (285)
      • Whatcom County (4)
      • Wyoming (4)
      • Yakima (11)

      Blog Archive

      • ►  2012 (1)
        • ►  February (1)
      • ►  2009 (98)
        • ►  July (5)
        • ►  June (10)
        • ►  May (6)
        • ►  April (12)
        • ►  March (19)
        • ►  February (20)
        • ►  January (26)
      • ►  2008 (297)
        • ►  December (16)
        • ►  November (20)
        • ►  October (24)
        • ►  September (23)
        • ►  August (23)
        • ►  July (24)
        • ►  June (28)
        • ►  May (23)
        • ►  April (21)
        • ►  March (25)
        • ►  February (29)
        • ►  January (41)
      • ►  2007 (387)
        • ►  December (36)
        • ►  November (19)
        • ►  October (28)
        • ►  September (35)
        • ►  August (35)
        • ►  July (31)
        • ►  June (28)
        • ►  May (37)
        • ►  April (36)
        • ►  March (28)
        • ►  February (25)
        • ►  January (49)
      • ►  2006 (520)
        • ►  December (40)
        • ►  November (33)
        • ►  October (33)
        • ►  September (43)
        • ►  August (46)
        • ►  July (28)
        • ►  June (65)
        • ►  May (56)
        • ►  April (53)
        • ►  March (39)
        • ►  February (47)
        • ►  January (37)
      • ▼  2005 (518)
        • ►  December (51)
        • ►  November (49)
        • ►  October (60)
        • ►  September (47)
        • ►  August (63)
        • ►  July (38)
        • ►  June (44)
        • ►  May (29)
        • ►  April (37)
        • ►  March (50)
        • ►  February (25)
        • ▼  January (25)
          • An honest judge
          • The worst attorney in the world
          • Maybe some of us need to take the refresher course...
          • Poor kitty
          • Never again
          • Favorable dicta
          • Cabela's good, Caballes bad, Caballes+Whren very, ...
          • Caballes consternation
          • Unleash the hounds
          • Lawyering becomes eclectic
          • Alma mater murder
          • Why-o, why-o, why-o (one reason I left Idaho)
          • "How many of you want to be on jury duty every day...
          • Difficult clients ar lietuviskai / на русском
          • How criminal law is like opera
          • An A1 tribute to a K9 officer
          • Back in the saddle again
          • How can we miss you if you won't leave?
          • Sharkey's day in court
          • A salute to the contract public defenders
          • Damn shame
          • Public defender versus shark lover
          • Quaint
          • Tip for attorney-client jail visits: try to stay o...
          • All is well, all is well
      • ►  2004 (165)
        • ►  December (29)
        • ►  November (32)
        • ►  October (25)
        • ►  September (25)
        • ►  August (33)
        • ►  July (21)
      Legal Disclaimer: Nothing here should be taken as legal advice. None of it is meant to be. People who take anything on this blog to be reliable legal advice probably should get out more often.

      Statcounter blog directory < A Legally Inclined Blawg > < 2007 "Rodneys" - Public Defender Blogger Awards >